Ought to our son surrender his US citizenship to scale back tax legal responsibility?

We’re British however our son, 19, was born within the US and has twin US/UK citizenship. We reside in Britain now and our son simply began college however we perceive he’s responsible for US tax on his worldwide earnings. What are his obligations and the way onerous are the implications? Is it simply earnings tax above sure ranges or might he face, for instance, US capital good points tax on promoting a future UK property? He’d prefer to preserve the choice to reside within the US, however assuming he doesn’t, is it higher financially to surrender his citizenship?

Jaime McLemore, companion in regulation agency Withers’ US/UK tax group, says: Congratulations, you have got . . . an American! Whereas for some folks a US passport is usually a golden ticket, for others it might probably really feel extra like an ever-increasing burden. The US, virtually uniquely (see additionally North Korea and Eritrea) taxes on the premise of citizenship, reasonably than simply residence and domicile.

You’re right that this implies your son is accountable for submitting US tax returns and probably paying some US tax on an annual foundation on his worldwide earnings.

The brink for having to file a US tax return is much decrease than within the UK and, sadly, submitting a US earnings tax return is simply the tip of the iceberg. There are additionally info returns, such because the infamous FBAR (to report non-US monetary accounts) and the dreaded Kind 3520 for things like presents, UK pensions and distributions from belief. These may not even result in an earnings tax legal responsibility however there’s a excessive penalty for non-filing.

There are additionally some traps for US residents dwelling within the UK, one among which you have got famous is US capital good points tax on the sale of a main residence by your son.

One other is Particular person Financial savings Accounts (Isas), which aren’t tax-free within the US. This is usually a double whammy if in case you have a shares and shares Isa, which is more likely to be invested solely in what the US tax jargon calls “passive overseas funding firms”. Suffice it to say these aren’t good investments on your son as a US citizen.

Trusts arrange by you or different relations on your son may also create further tax and reporting burdens as these are virtually actually non-US trusts, the earnings and investments of which (bear in mind PFICs?) should be fastidiously managed in order that your son doesn’t face a disproportionate US tax legal responsibility when he receives distributions or advantages.

Despite all this (and there’s extra), many US residents will put up with the tax and compliance burden with a view to preserve their US citizenship. The choice to surrender US citizenship is a deeply particular person one and there’s no single metric to find out whether or not it’s higher to maintain it or give it up.

The authorized entitlement to reside and work within the US sooner or later sooner or later might be sufficient of a profit to place up with the entire angst. In case your son needs to maintain his citizenship, then the suitable advisers could make the US tax and compliance burden really feel manageable and routine. If, nevertheless, he decides the advantages aren’t well worth the prices, there’s a course of to expatriate accessible by the US embassy. Take care, nevertheless — however there is usually a tax for that too.

We’re promoting our household residence within the English countryside. The house is surrounded by paddocks and a small river with fishing rights on each banks. We consider that as it’s our principal residence, the sale with the land is free from tax. HMRC has instructed that this isn’t the case and that simply 0.5 of a hectare qualifies. Is that right?

Alice Pearson, a companion at chartered accountants Mercer & Gap, says: It’s well-known that predominant residence reduction can exempt a acquire realised on the sale of your house from capital good points tax. This consists of backyard or grounds as much as the “permitted space”, outlined as 0.5 of a hectare.

Nonetheless, a bigger plot of land may very well be included the place it’s “required for the affordable enjoyment” of the home. It is a gray space that requires some cautious thought.

First, it is advisable set up to what extent the land constitutes backyard or grounds. If that is enclosed land surrounding your house that’s maybe used for recreation or rising flowers, it’s more likely to qualify. Even when the land isn’t actively used, your paddocks might represent “grounds” offered there is no such thing as a enterprise use.

Second, you need to decide how a lot of the backyard or grounds are required for the affordable enjoyment of the home contemplating its dimension and character. In response to HMRC, “required” pertains to want reasonably than what is just fascinating.

Case regulation recognises that it’s the home you need to take into account and never the pursuits of the proprietor. Subsequently, if you’re a eager angler, this might not assist an argument that the riverside land is required for the enjoyment of the property.

Nonetheless, the fishing rights connected to the land present privateness for the property. With out these rights strangers might entry your backyard to fish, which I think about would hinder the enjoyment of the home. Subsequently, arguably this land is required to make the most of the rights and protect the privateness of the property.

The agricultural location of your property must also be taken into consideration. It was efficiently argued in a current case of a property with land of 0.94 hectares that the agricultural location would enchantment to someone on the lookout for a bigger home and extra space round it was required for privateness and outside pursuits.

The supportive proof confirmed that comparable homes within the neighbourhood all had bigger gardens too and, because the taxpayer’s home was proportionately greater, it required extra grounds. With this in thoughts, I might counsel chatting with an area property agent to search for comparisons and gauge the market expectation in your space.

It is a frequent space of disagreement with HMRC. Should you do declare land in extra of half a hectare, I like to recommend full disclosure of the explanations in your tax return. That is to forestall prolonged HMRC inquiry deadlines and to guard your penalty place, if HMRC have been to efficiently problem the declare.

The opinions on this column are supposed for normal info functions solely and shouldn’t be used as an alternative choice to skilled recommendation. The Monetary Occasions Ltd and the authors aren’t accountable for any direct or oblique end result arising from any reliance positioned on replies, together with any loss, and exclude legal responsibility to the total extent.

Do you have got a monetary dilemma that you simply’d like FT Cash’s group {of professional} specialists to look into? E-mail your downside in confidence to yourquestions@ft.com